Big Pine Key, FL · October 2026

Big Pine Key market snapshot

Distressed inventory, home values and rents in Big Pine Key, refreshed every month.

See all 47 listings
Distressed homes
47
Median home value
$721,765
Median rent
$2,490/mo
12-month value change
+5.2%

Home values over the past year

The median Big Pine Key home moved from $686,394 in Oct 2025 to $721,765 in Oct 2026, +5.2%.

$731,430 $686,394
Oct 2025 Jan Apr Jul Oct 2026

Median rent

$2,490/mo

Price range

Sample homes across the Big Pine Key market.

Entry
$228,400
Typical
$714,738
Upper end
$1,576,238

This month

Home values: +0.56% MoM; rent: +0.00% MoM.

  1. Oct 2025 $686,394
  2. Nov 2025 $687,659
  3. Dec 2025 $691,785
  4. Jan 2026 $697,000
  5. Feb 2026 $697,787
  6. Mar 2026 $702,988
  7. Apr 2026 $714,459
  8. May 2026 $724,033
  9. Jun 2026 $731,430
  10. Jul 2026 $725,225
  11. Aug 2026 $720,584
  12. Sep 2026 $717,731
  13. Oct 2026 $721,765

What's for sale

Active distressed listings in Big Pine Key, by type.

Distressed listings in Big Pine Key

A selection of what's on the market now. Inventory changes daily.

Palm Dr, Big Pine Key Preforeclosure 2 $566,061EMV Palm Dr Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 2 2 1030 Est. rent $2,680 Built 1976
Oleander Dr, Big Pine Key Preforeclosure $540,527EMV Oleander Dr Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 1.0 1378 Est. rent $2,940
Avenue E, Big Pine Key Preforeclosure $728,783EMV Avenue E Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 2 1638 Est. rent $3,060 Built 2006
Avenue D, Big Pine Key Preforeclosure $730,711EMV Avenue D Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 1.5 1544 Est. rent $3,360 Built 2004
Ave E, Big Pine Key Preforeclosure Price coming soon Ave E Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 1.0 1352
Avenue C, Big Pine Key Preforeclosure $543,704EMV Avenue C Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 2 2 1451 Est. rent $2,900 Built 1987
Avenue C, Big Pine Key Bankruptcy $306,079EMV Avenue C Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 1.0 1269 Est. rent $0
Avenue B # B, Big Pine Key Tax lien Price coming soon Avenue B # B Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 2 1.0 1352
Coral Way, Big Pine Key Tax lien $1,548,659EMV Coral Way Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 1.0 2046 Est. rent $3,460
Long Beach Dr, Big Pine Key Tax lien $1,638,722EMV Long Beach Dr Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 3 1.0 4182 Est. rent $4,020
Watson Blvd, Big Pine Key Tax lien $531,987EMV Watson Blvd Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Single-Family 2 1.0 1558 Est. rent $3,020
Avenue F, Big Pine Key Tax lien $568,905EMV Avenue F Big Pine Key, FL 33043 Mobile Home 3 1.0 1294 Est. rent $0
See all 47 listings in Big Pine Key

Schools nearby

Close to homes for sale in Big Pine Key.

  • Big Pine Academy
  • Sugarloaf School
  • Marathon Middle High School
  • Key West High School
  • Florida Keys Community College

Get the Big Pine Key snapshot every month

Plus an email whenever new distressed listings appear in Big Pine Key, FL. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Home values and rents are city-wide medians as of October 2026. Listing counts are live and cover active foreclosure, preforeclosure, auction and other distressed properties in Big Pine Key, FL.

Equal Housing Opportunity
Privacy Policy   |   Terms and Conditions of Service   |   © Foreclosure.com / ForeclosureFreeSearch.com 1999-2026. All Rights Reserved.