Garnerville, NY · September 2026

Garnerville market snapshot

Distressed inventory, home values and rents in Garnerville, refreshed every month.

See all 21 listings
Distressed homes
21
Median home value
$674,196
Median rent
$2,460/mo
12-month value change
+5.5%

Home values over the past year

The median Garnerville home moved from $639,210 in Sep 2025 to $674,196 in Sep 2026, +5.5%.

$674,196 $611,488
Sep 2025 Dec Mar Jun Sep 2026

Median rent

$2,460/mo

Price range

Sample homes across the Garnerville market.

Entry
$366,446
Typical
$673,224
Upper end
$1,009,481

This month

Home values: +0.32% MoM; rent: +0.00% MoM.

  1. Sep 2025 $639,210
  2. Oct 2025 $635,643
  3. Nov 2025 $625,353
  4. Dec 2025 $622,673
  5. Jan 2026 $611,488
  6. Feb 2026 $617,497
  7. Mar 2026 $627,277
  8. Apr 2026 $627,435
  9. May 2026 $632,075
  10. Jun 2026 $646,200
  11. Jul 2026 $662,926
  12. Aug 2026 $672,041
  13. Sep 2026 $674,196

What's for sale

Active distressed listings in Garnerville, by type.

Distressed listings in Garnerville

A selection of what's on the market now. Inventory changes daily.

Hickory Ln, Garnerville Foreclosure $773,549EMV Hickory Ln Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 6 3.0 2841 Est. rent $3,820
Main St, Garnerville Preforeclosure $514,476EMV Main St Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 3 2 1646 Est. rent $2,770 Built 1900
Eakman Dr, Garnerville Preforeclosure 5 $601,755EMV Eakman Dr Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 4 1.5 1804 Est. rent $2,730 Built 1973
Hester Pl, Garnerville Preforeclosure $452,713EMV Hester Pl Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 3 1.5 1480 Est. rent $2,750
Ossman Ct, Garnerville Preforeclosure $376,405EMV Ossman Ct Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 3 2.5 1350 Est. rent $2,710
Vandenberg Cir, Garnerville Preforeclosure $930,970EMV Vandenberg Cir Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 4 2.5 3111 Est. rent $3,240
Capt Shankey Dr, Garnerville Preforeclosure $428,872EMV Capt Shankey Dr Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 3 2.0 912 Est. rent $2,610
Fahey Dr, Garnerville Preforeclosure $394,159EMV Fahey Dr Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 2 1.5 1528 Est. rent $2,670
Trimble St, Garnerville Preforeclosure $534,592EMV Trimble St Garnerville, NY 10923 Multi-Family 5 2.0 2208 Est. rent $3,130
Kinsman Ln, Garnerville Preforeclosure $437,110EMV Kinsman Ln Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 2 1.0 720 Est. rent $2,670
Oldfield Ct, Garnerville Preforeclosure 5 $753,629EMV Oldfield Ct Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 4 2.5 2250 Est. rent $3,240 Built 1994
Lilac Ln, Garnerville Bankruptcy $669,502EMV Lilac Ln Garnerville, NY 10923 Single-Family 4 2.0 1960 Est. rent $2,970
See all 21 listings in Garnerville

Schools nearby

Close to homes for sale in Garnerville.

  • Garnerville Elementary School
  • Fieldstone Middle School
  • North Rockland High School
  • Haverstraw Elementary School
  • Thiells Elementary School

Get the Garnerville snapshot every month

Plus an email whenever new distressed listings appear in Garnerville, NY. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Home values and rents are city-wide medians as of September 2026. Listing counts are live and cover active foreclosure, preforeclosure, auction and other distressed properties in Garnerville, NY.

Equal Housing Opportunity
Privacy Policy   |   Terms and Conditions of Service   |   © Foreclosure.com / ForeclosureFreeSearch.com 1999-2026. All Rights Reserved.