Jay, FL · October 2026

Jay market snapshot

Distressed inventory, home values and rents in Jay, refreshed every month.

See all 314 listings

Distressed homes: 314
Median home value: $255,021
Median rent: $1,020/mo
12-month value change: +9.4%

Home values over the past year

The median Jay home moved from $233,012 in Oct 2025 to $255,021 in Oct 2026, +9.4%.

$262,917 $227,481

Oct 2025 Jan Apr Jul Oct 2026

Median rent

$1,020/mo -1.0%

$1,030 $1,020

Oct 2025 Jan Apr Jul Oct 2026

Price range

Sample homes across the Jay market.

Entry: $65,264
Typical: $238,882
Upper end: $629,600

This month

Home values: -2.43% MoM; rent: +0.00% MoM.

Oct 2025 $233,012
Nov 2025 $228,605
Dec 2025 $227,481
Jan 2026 $246,858
Feb 2026 $245,417
Mar 2026 $247,803
Apr 2026 $247,870
May 2026 $258,947
Jun 2026 $261,347
Jul 2026 $260,904
Aug 2026 $262,917
Sep 2026 $261,384
Oct 2026 $255,021

What's for sale

Active distressed listings in Jay, by type.

Tax lien 303
Preforeclosure 5
Bankruptcy 4
Foreclosure 2

Distressed listings in Jay

A selection of what's on the market now. Inventory changes daily.

Foreclosure 3 $43,891EMV Dykestown Rd Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 2 1 1008 Est. rent $680 Built 1980

Foreclosure $77,836EMV Nelsontown Rd Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 3 2.0 848 Est. rent $780

Preforeclosure $205,410EMV Highway 178 Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 3 2.0 1486 Est. rent $1,160

Preforeclosure $245,886EMV Dykestown Rd Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 3 2.0 0 Est. rent $1,291

Bankruptcy $322,278EMV James Jernigan Rd Jay, FL 32565 Agricultural 3 2.0 2142 Est. rent $1,230

Tax lien $111,206EMV Scott St Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 2 1.0 1838 Est. rent $1,090

Tax lien $218,202EMV Elliott Ln Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 2 2.0 1899 Est. rent $1,408

Tax lien $295,032EMV Highway 4 Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 3 2.0 1635 Est. rent $1,171

Tax lien $202,836EMV New York St Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 3 2.0 1421 Est. rent $1,220

Tax lien $131,657EMV Highway 4 Jay, FL 32565 Single-Family 2 1.0 1378 Est. rent $870

Tax lien $287,397EMV Spring St Jay, FL 32565 Multi-Family 6 4.0 2091 Est. rent $1,410

Tax lien Price coming soon Highway 87 N Jay, FL 32565 Agricultural 3 2.0 1352

See all 314 listings in Jay

Schools nearby

Close to homes for sale in Jay.

Jay Elementary School
Jay High School
Central School
Chumuckla Elementary School
S.S. Dixon Intermediate School

Get the Jay snapshot every month

Plus an email whenever new distressed listings appear in Jay, FL. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Home values and rents are city-wide medians as of October 2026. Listing counts are live and cover active foreclosure, preforeclosure, auction and other distressed properties in Jay, FL.