Lancaster, NY · September 2026

Lancaster market snapshot

Distressed inventory, home values and rents in Lancaster, refreshed every month.

See all 41 listings
Distressed homes
41
Median home value
$405,299
Median rent
$1,630/mo
12-month value change
+7.4%

Home values over the past year

The median Lancaster home moved from $377,464 in Sep 2025 to $405,299 in Sep 2026, +7.4%.

$405,299 $367,162
Sep 2025 Dec Mar Jun Sep 2026

Median rent

$1,630/mo

Price range

Sample homes across the Lancaster market.

Entry
$204,981
Typical
$404,015
Upper end
$694,310

This month

Home values: +0.65% MoM; rent: +0.00% MoM.

  1. Sep 2025 $377,464
  2. Oct 2025 $376,159
  3. Nov 2025 $373,077
  4. Dec 2025 $368,128
  5. Jan 2026 $373,610
  6. Feb 2026 $371,392
  7. Mar 2026 $368,817
  8. Apr 2026 $367,162
  9. May 2026 $368,941
  10. Jun 2026 $379,758
  11. Jul 2026 $395,269
  12. Aug 2026 $402,678
  13. Sep 2026 $405,299

What's for sale

Active distressed listings in Lancaster, by type.

Distressed listings in Lancaster

A selection of what's on the market now. Inventory changes daily.

Broadway St, Lancaster Foreclosure $247,375EMV Broadway St Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 3 2 1261 Est. rent $1,430 Built 1929
Broadway St, Lancaster Preforeclosure $216,904EMV Broadway St Lancaster, NY 14086 Multi-Family 6 2.5 2838 Est. rent $1,171
William St, Lancaster Preforeclosure Price coming soon William St Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 3 1.0 1393
Church St, Lancaster Preforeclosure $281,755EMV Church St Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 4 1.5 2020 Est. rent $1,790
Ransom Rd, Lancaster Preforeclosure $563,773EMV Ransom Rd Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 4 2.5 2769 Est. rent $2,310
Pleasant Vw Dr, Depew Preforeclosure Price coming soon Pleasant Vw Dr Depew, NY 14043 Single-Family 3 1.5 2843
Edgewood Rd, Lancaster Preforeclosure $238,056EMV Edgewood Rd Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 2 1.0 1400 Est. rent $1,610
4th Ave, Lancaster Preforeclosure $170,030EMV 4th Ave Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 2 1.0 936 Est. rent $1,321
Harold Pl, Lancaster Preforeclosure $233,825EMV Harold Pl Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 2 1.0 1426 Est. rent $1,500
Apple Blossom Blvd, Lancaster Preforeclosure $503,304EMV Apple Blossom Blvd Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 3 2.5 2258 Est. rent $2,160
Albert Dr, Lancaster Preforeclosure $257,566EMV Albert Dr Lancaster, NY 14086 Single-Family 3 2.0 1344 Est. rent $1,620
Holland Ave, Lancaster Preforeclosure $252,107EMV Holland Ave Lancaster, NY 14086 Multi-Family 4 2.5 2032 Est. rent $1,110
See all 41 listings in Lancaster

Schools nearby

Close to homes for sale in Lancaster.

  • Lancaster High School
  • Lancaster Middle School
  • William Street School
  • Como Park Elementary School
  • Court Street Elementary School

Get the Lancaster snapshot every month

Plus an email whenever new distressed listings appear in Lancaster, NY. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Home values and rents are city-wide medians as of September 2026. Listing counts are live and cover active foreclosure, preforeclosure, auction and other distressed properties in Lancaster, NY.

Equal Housing Opportunity
Privacy Policy   |   Terms and Conditions of Service   |   © Foreclosure.com / ForeclosureFreeSearch.com 1999-2026. All Rights Reserved.