Smithtown, NY · October 2026

Smithtown market snapshot

Distressed inventory, home values and rents in Smithtown, refreshed every month.

See all 50 listings
Distressed homes
50
Median home value
$816,567
Median rent
$2,750/mo
12-month value change
+7.7%

Home values over the past year

The median Smithtown home moved from $758,512 in Oct 2025 to $816,567 in Oct 2026, +7.7%.

$816,567 $758,512
Oct 2025 Jan Apr Jul Oct 2026

Median rent

$2,750/mo

Price range

Sample homes across the Smithtown market.

Entry
$573,000
Typical
$815,822
Upper end
$1,207,080

This month

Home values: +1.25% MoM; rent: +0.00% MoM.

  1. Oct 2025 $758,512
  2. Nov 2025 $769,813
  3. Dec 2025 $772,805
  4. Jan 2026 $774,855
  5. Feb 2026 $772,546
  6. Mar 2026 $775,006
  7. Apr 2026 $775,882
  8. May 2026 $776,801
  9. Jun 2026 $782,167
  10. Jul 2026 $789,962
  11. Aug 2026 $796,887
  12. Sep 2026 $806,498
  13. Oct 2026 $816,567

What's for sale

Active distressed listings in Smithtown, by type.

Distressed listings in Smithtown

A selection of what's on the market now. Inventory changes daily.

Wood Ln, Smithtown Preforeclosure $899,727EMV Wood Ln Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 3 1.5 2173 Est. rent $3,260 Built 1959
Oakside Dr # A, Smithtown Preforeclosure $952,421EMV Oakside Dr # A Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 2.5 1998 Est. rent $3,880
Cindy St, Smithtown Preforeclosure $708,180EMV Cindy St Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 3 1.5 1700 Est. rent $3,140
Judges Ln, Smithtown Preforeclosure $729,962EMV Judges Ln Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 2 1.0 952 Est. rent $2,800
Franklin Dr, Smithtown Preforeclosure $832,236EMV Franklin Dr Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 2.5 3091 Est. rent $3,880 Built 2000
Oakside Dr, Smithtown Preforeclosure Price coming soon Oakside Dr Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 3 2 1998 Built 1985
Ruth St, Smithtown Preforeclosure Price coming soon Ruth St Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 3 1943 Built 2023
Periwinkle Ct, Smithtown Preforeclosure $725,480EMV Periwinkle Ct Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 2.5 2669 Est. rent $3,370 Built 2000
Colonial Dr, Smithtown Preforeclosure $1,389,556EMV Colonial Dr Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 4.0 0 Est. rent $4,460
Frank St, Smithtown Preforeclosure $721,650EMV Frank St Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 3 1.5 2164 Est. rent $2,900 Built 1973
Meadow Rd, Smithtown Preforeclosure $790,247EMV Meadow Rd Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 1.5 2730 Est. rent $4,320 Built 1974
Edgewood Ave, Smithtown Preforeclosure $736,327EMV Edgewood Ave Smithtown, NY 11787 Single-Family 4 1.5 2268 Est. rent $3,600 Built 1937
See all 50 listings in Smithtown

Schools nearby

Close to homes for sale in Smithtown.

  • Smithtown High School East
  • Smithtown High School West
  • Accompsett Middle School
  • Great Hollow Middle School
  • Nesaquake Middle School

Get the Smithtown snapshot every month

Plus an email whenever new distressed listings appear in Smithtown, NY. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Home values and rents are city-wide medians as of October 2026. Listing counts are live and cover active foreclosure, preforeclosure, auction and other distressed properties in Smithtown, NY.

Equal Housing Opportunity
Privacy Policy   |   Terms and Conditions of Service   |   © Foreclosure.com / ForeclosureFreeSearch.com 1999-2026. All Rights Reserved.