foreclosure.com

Foreclosure Homes in Shirley, NY

Search within map
Price
Listing Type Up arrow
Property Type Up arrow
Displaying 1 - 10 of 122

Shirley, NY Foreclosures

Current Market Conditions in Shirley, NY as of August 2026?
Home values: +1.43% MoM; rent: +0.35% MoM.
How much do homes sell for in Shirley, NY?
The average home price is currently $538,606.
In Shirley, NY, how many homes are available?
There are currently 122 active home listings available in Shirley.
What’s the average rental cost in Shirley, NY?
The average rental price in Shirley is $2,841.
What is the most expensive home in Shirley?
The most expensive home sold in Shirley had a price of $6,105,675.
What is currently the cheapest priced home in Shirley, NY?
The cheapest home for sale in Shirley is priced at $10,038.

Living in Shirley, NY

Shirley is a South Shore Suffolk County hamlet offering relatively accessible Long Island housing, LIRR connectivity, major road access, and close proximity to beaches, wildlife preserves, and bayfront recreation.

Buyer vs Seller Market in Shirley, NY

Median home value: $536,143 as of 2026-08-14.

Median rent: $2,880 as of 2026-08-14.

Home values: +1.43% MoM, +5.52% YoY.

Rent: +0.35% MoM, +0.35% YoY.

Home Value Estimator For Shirley, NY

There are currently 7,632 real estate properties in Shirley, NY, with a median automated valuation model (AVM) price of $536,143.00. What is an AVM? It is a smart computer program that analyzes and predicts the approximate value of a home, property or land in Shirley, NY, based on current market trends, comparable real estate sales nearby, historical data and, of course, property features, among other variables. These automated home estimates are often very helpful, providing buyers and sellers with a better idea of a home’s value ahead of the negotiation process. For example, the average home price in Shirley, NY, is $538,606.00, with the most expensive house in Shirley, NY, topping out at $6,105,675.00 and the cheapest home in Shirley, NY, clocking in at $10,038.00. In other words, there’s something for every potential homebuyer or savvy investor in Shirley, NY!

Rent Prices In Shirley, NY

With the expiration of certain local, state and federal housing-related restrictions and mandated programs, the rental market in Shirley, NY, is on a rollercoaster ride. The average rent price in Shirley, NY, is $2,841.00. Indeed, when looking to rent in Shirley, NY, you can expect to pay as little as $1,600.00 or as much as $4,220.00, with the average rent median estimated to be $2,880.00. The good news is that finding an affordable and desirable property to rent in Shirley, NY -- whether it’s apartments, townhomes, condominiums or single-family homes -- is made easier with knowledge of the local market and, of course, a little patience.

Shirley, NY Foreclosures

Market Trend for Shirley, NY

Total Listings Available: 122

Market Values:

Home Prices from $10,038 to $6,105,675

Average Sales Price: $538,606

Rental Values:

Rental from $1,600 to $4,220

Average Rent Value: $2,841 / month

Popular Searches

Nearby Areas

Nearby Zip Codes

Get NEW Foreclosure Listings sent to your inbox

Millions of people receive foreclosure alerts daily, don't miss out.

No Thanks | Remind Me Later
Equal Housing Opportunity
Privacy Policy   |   Terms and Conditions of Service   |   © Foreclosure.com / ForeclosureFreeSearch.com 1999-2026. All Rights Reserved.